in ,

Guilbeau: Bama And Georgia Are Great Teams, But Buildup Of This Rematch National Championship Will Be A Challenge

Videos by OutKick

The late, great South Carolina columnist Ken Burger once wrote:

“I love women. I love college basketball. But I hate women’s college basketball.”

This is how I feel about the upcoming national championship college football game between No. 1 Alabama (13-1) and No. 3 Georgia (13-1) in Indianapolis on Jan. 10.

I love college football. I’ve always liked Alabama coach Nick Saban, going back to before he was the greatest college football coach of all time when he was at LSU. I’ve always liked his coaching son, Georgia coach Kirby Smart, ever since getting to talk to him at length at a media party Saban held at his house in Baton Rouge in 2004. And I love big games.

But I hate this game. I will watch it. I will have to. It’s part of the job. But they just played on Dec. 4 for the SEC title, and the Crimson Tide drowned the Bulldogs, 41-24, like it beat Cincinnati, 27-6, on Friday and like Georgia beat Michigan, 34-11, on Friday night.

And these two already played for the national championship on Jan. 8, 2018, with Alabama winning a classic, 26-23, in overtime, and Alabama beat the Bulldogs again later that same year in the 2018 SEC title game, 35-28.

This feels like the third or fourth Super Bowl for the Buffalo Bills, who are 0-4 in such games.

Now, had Georgia beat Alabama in the first game this season, this one would not be as bad because you knew Saban would figure something out like he always does the next time he plays somebody, or nearly die trying. But with Alabama winning so convincingly the first time and Saban still on its sideline, this is not looking like a good game.

Throw in the strange point spread that has Georgia favored by 2.5 points, which falls right into Saban’s hands, and this one’s already over.

Alabama has defeated Georgia seven straight times going back to 2008, including three SEC Championship games in all. Smart is a Buffalo-like 0-for-4 against Saban with the national championship loss after leading 13-0 at the half and 20-7 late in the third. Smart also led that 2018 SEC title game, 24-20 at the half, and he led Alabama last month, 10-0 in the second quarter.

Georgia’s present players weren’t around for most of that 0-for-7, but that doesn’t matter. Those kind of things carry on through teams.

Georgia will never admit it, but it has an inferiority complex about Alabama, period. Smart will never admit it, but he has an inferiority complex about Saban, too. Sure, Smart knows a lot about Saban as a coach since he coached under him from 2007 through 2015 at Alabama and coached and with the Miami Dolphins in 2005 and at LSU in 2004. But advantage to the coach who’s coaching the coach in this case.

Saban knows so much about Smart that Smart must feel like Saban’s watching him practice and game plan. At least that’s what it seems like in their head-to-head matches, particularly with the leads Smart has blown.

The LSU-Alabama rematch in the national championship on Jan. 9, 2012 in New Orleans, was not as bad as this one going in because the Tigers had defeated the Tide, 9-6, in overtime two months previously. That was obviously a much closer game, and Alabama outgained LSU, 295 to 239, and missed three field goals. LSU safety Eric Reid also made a spectacular interception in the end zone that would have been a Bama touchdown had the pass had a little more loft as the receiver was open. So, that game had a freakish element to it.

Not so in Alabama’s win over Georgia a month ago. And not so in Alabama’s 41-24 win over Georgia in the 2020 regular season. In the end, not even close.

And it’s hard not to assume Alabama will win by about 41-24 again on Jan. 10. It would be so much more fun if Cincinnati was playing Georgia or Michigan was playing Alabama.

It would have been more fun if LSU had played Oklahoma State back on Jan. 9, 2012, instead of Alabama, too. That would have happened had the No. 2 and 10-0 Cowboys not lost to 5-4 Iowa State. Instead, Alabama beat LSU, 21-0, in one of the worst championship games in any sport of all time. That’s what I feel like is about to happen again.

Georgia-Alabama is the first rematch in a national title game in the College Football Playoff era, which began in 2014, and the first since that Alabama-LSU game.

You know, Smart would rather see another jersey as he laboriously studies Alabama film this week.

“I want to get focused on Alabama,” he said after the win over Michigan. “They got a five- or six-hour head start.”

Actually, it’s more like a 10-year head start with Saban as coach. And I doubt if Saban has even looked at Georgia film yet. He just did that a month ago.

Saban will have a difficult task in the coming days convincing his players and himself deep inside that Georgia can actually beat his team. He would probably prefer seeing another team on film this week, too, if he watches any.

Written by Glenn Guilbeau

Guilbeau has been on the LSU beat since 1998 with multiple outlets in Louisiana, prior to that he had covered both Auburn and Alabama. He won first place for his game feature on LSU's upset at Florida last season from the Football Writers Association of America (FWAA). He was also named Beat Writer of Year, by Louisiana Sports Writers Association in July; placed in three Associated Press Sports Editors (APSE) categories – Beat Writer, Explanatory, Game Coverage – last spring. Guilbeau was also the FWAA first-place winner for columns in 2017 and was also the top overall winner in 2016 FWAA placing first for his game story, second in columns, and receiving honorable mention for features.

One Comment

Leave a Reply
  1. There is such an ingrained bias to the National Championships. Of course, both teams are great and deserve to be there. However, if you want to find out which team is the best all around you’d have to occasionally have semi final and championship games in cold weather. How do you suppose Alabama or Georgia would do in Madison Wisconsin in January? The powers that be will never have that as it has been determined that track athletes on offense make a more watchable game than 330 pound bulldozers in the trenches making room for a 240 pound RB taking 4 or 5 yards a crack. In addition, how many Alabama or Georgia fans would brave the cold to travel to the game. No, no, we can’t have that.
    Every important bowl game is on a fast track in warm weather. Is it any wonder the SEC dominates?
    P.S. sorry for the rant.

Leave a Reply

to comment on this post. Not a VIP? Signup Here